The above question was asked about a week and a half ago in the form of a club evening by the same name. Three bands from way back -- favourites from my youth -- were booked to play at the ridiculously overpriced and generally crappy Kuudes Linja (which can not be disparaged enough by me) on what turned out to be the wettest Wednesday ever. The results of that evening were mixed: a general nostalgia for times when indie was still fun, teary-eyed appreciation of some kick-ass bands playing killer tunes, and a righteus fury at the sad contemporary state of indie pop, which led to redfaced rants of how Joy division is overrated crap and only got better when that sad bastard Ian Curits offed himself, etc.
A handful of people had gathered, and as I stood there in my soggy sneakers the rather desolate atmosphere was bringing me down as much as the music was lifting me up. Luckily the audience made up in quality what it lacked in quantity. After hearing the last 20 minutes of a smashing set by Vaasa power-popsters Sugarrush, I was blown away by the rousing applause they got. They are still one of my favourite bands, and I can only hope their dayjobs are well-paid but boring enough for them to keep wasting time playing in a rock'n'roll band -- even if they no longer play just to desperately attrack chicks (which I'm sure such a handsome bunch does quite successfully). I just wish they had played last: they're born showstoppers. After Sugarrush Ben's Diapers' country rock made me wonder when exactly did country go out of fashion? Just a few years ago it was all Americana everywhere, with the Jayhawks, Wilco, Iron & Wine, Ryan Adams, and the likes soaking indie-kids' underwear left and right. All of the sudden nobody cares about the dusty roadside bars and prairie fires. Go figure. Anyway, I declare Ben's Diapers' (who clearly have no interest in mainstream success, based on the moniker they have chosen) song Road Songs an instant classic in the niche of Finnish-guitar-driven-alt.country-pop. Finally it was Mummypower who closed the show with a set that revealed a previously undiscovered, striking resemblance to Smashing Pumpkins! (By way of The Posies, of course.)
All in all, some powerful spirits were channelled throughout the evening -- The Posies, The Pixies, Paul Westerberg, Evan Dando -- luminaries of Power Pop, whom the world of indie seems to have all but forgotten. Finnish indie pop as a genre, I guess, has been slipping into hibernation since the turn of the millennium. The bands I used to listen to and love when I first moved into Helsinki are almost gone -- they've gotten married, they're raising kids, working dayjobs, etc. There's a charming sense of passing in that. And the bands that have come up to fill those voids naurally build on new ideas and recycle different sounds. But at the same time I can't help but feel a new kind of self-conscious coolness about most of the new bands on the scene -- an artistry that's ill-fitting to the
philosophy of indie pop I have come to embrace. Of course, Finland is another story from the US-UK axis which gave birth to most of these sounds, and the indie pop scene here in the 90s was always more syncretic than its agloamerican paragons. The dissolving of Finland's wave of guitar-pop was not as inevitable the fate of those highly developed counter-cool movements. But times have indeed changed here as well, and with a quick tally of the contemporary hot shit on the scene, the loss of innocence is achingly tangible. It's all somehow more professional, more ambitious, more serious than I remember. Indie pop has ceased to exist, and only the grim reality of "indie" in the American sense of music that's hip and fashionable among a certain strata of educated youth, or in the British sense of music that's made with guitars and not computers, prevails.
I'm not out to badmouth anyone or claim that Finnish bands nowadays lack in the DIY department. I'm just saying that the empowering potential that indie pop has held for geeks has ebbed (and I mean true geeks, the uncool kids, not the "geeks" who dig indie music, because they're really not uncool at all, are they).
To shape that rather esoteric conclusion into the form of an answer to that titular question: what was indie?
Just a bunch of kids having fun.